MapleLeafMerc said:
The USSR, Soviet Union, Mother Russia, et cetera, was held up by liberals around the world for YEARS as God's gift to good government, yet has delivered more misery than benefit.
I think there's an easy answer to this one... honestly!
Here it is:
Human nature.
Think about it, we're programmed to survive, like every other living organism. And many organisms fight to survive by accumulating as much power and/or resources as possible. In our case, that can be taken one step further and called
greed. And, unique to our species, let's throw in a dash of
laziness to boot.
So let's say someone honestly does have a vision where everyone can live life easier knowing they can 100% count on everyone else to give them a hand in everything they may do. This person envisions a community where activities are shared equally, harvests are shared equally, wealth is shared equally... essentially, one never again has to worry about dealing with a bout of bad luck, because they'll always have that buffer of a 100% supportive community to help them through the rough times, just as they will help support those in need. Nice idea, no?
Now, let's apply this to the human being...
There will be disputes over how the community is run. Eventually, a leader is chosen. That leader, in a position of power, will
by human nature want to reap the benefits of his position of power. Eventually, with enough power, the temptation will be there to keep a little something exclusively for himself. If he doesn't do it, someone else will, right?
And there you have it... can we really see the people in power
wanting to give up those perks? Of course, they'll do ANYTHING to hang on to that cushy way of life. And when the will of the people is suppressed in order to maintain that status quo, a dictatorship becomes reality. Those wanting to remain in the favour of the rulers will play the game along with them, and reap benefits proportional to their ranking vis à vis the ruling class. After all, it's their way of survival.
So, by definition, communism does not equal dictatorship. Communism PLUS human nature eventually equals dictatorship. No way around it.